Fair Hill Pizza, located at 356 Fair Hill Dr in Elkton, MD, stands out as a beloved local pizzeria with a reputation for delightful dishes and warm hospitality. Customers rave about the tasty, sweet sauce that accompanies their pizzas; many highlight the signature large 16" cheese pizza, often paired with wings for a diverse dining experience. Reviewers like Andrew O appreciate the friendly staff who go above and beyond, even offering tours to amuse children and create a welcoming environment. Beyond pizza, Fair Hill Pizza boasts an extensive menu featuring enticing entrees like baked ziti and chicken parmigiana, as well as delightful desserts such as tiramisu and carrot cake. Joshua H emphasizes their delicious hot subs and Strombolis, particularly the Philly Special Cheese Steak and Buffalo Chicken Roll, which have gained loyal fans. Diane Buchanan, a new resident, describes it as a "cute little pizza place," praising the combination of excellent flavors and consistently appealing food. Overall, Fair Hill Pizza has established itself as a go-to destination for quality pizza and friendly service, making it a must-visit in Elkton. Whether you're after a comforting slice or a hearty meal, Fair Hill Pizza promises satisfaction and a sense of community.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves comfort food
Quick bite
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has catering
Serves dessert
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Crowd
Good for groups
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Has kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Photos
Reviews For Fair Hill Pizza
Andrew O
May 27,2025
Tried their pizza while camping nearby and absolutely loved it! The sauce is sweet and reminds me of tomato soup. Staff is super friendly and even cheered up my hangry toddler by giving him a behind the counter tour and a small bag of chips. Looking forward to trying other items on their extensive menu soon.
Joshua H
May 18,2025
Always a pretty decent meal. Prices are good and consistent. I dont eat the pizza here but enjoy all the different hot subs I have had. Their "rolls" which are mini Strombolis are delicious as well. Try the Philly Special Cheese Steak, the Rueben Sub, the Buffalo Chicken Roll, or the Sausage Special Roll. These are all my fovorites at this place.
Tori
May 7,2025
Best pizza in the area! The owner is friendly and the food is great! This is the only local pizza place that we have found that remains consistent. Would 100% recommend!
John Price
Apr 1,2025
I'm in the area for a few days and have tried Mario's before on a previous trip, so I thought I'd give this a try. Ordered a plain pie with sausage. I had no issues with it and thought it was pretty decent. Another reviewer mentioned the sauce being a little too sweet for their liking. I understand it, but I was okay with it. I think they may use San Marzano tomatoes, which are naturally more sweet than what is grown domestically. Prices were fair, and the owners (I think they were owners) were friendly and amusing.
Diane Buchanan
Mar 26,2025
Recently moved near by and googled pizza places. Was not disappointed. Our pizza was so good! It will be one of our favorite go to places. We ordered and picked up. Then went another time and ate in. Had pizza again and wings. Very yummy. It's a cute little pizza place.
Michael N.
Mar 7,2025
This place is phenomenal. I have been here several times, and I am always very satisfied with the pizza. I highly recommend this place.
Dominic Chickadel
Mar 3,2025
Best pizza in the area. Good flavor and crust compared to where I live.
Bob Myers
Feb 11,2025
I often order a turkey sub but everything ordered has been great. Friendly devoted owners go the extra mile. Love this place
Reviews For Fair Hill Pizza